What Would It Take to Say We Found Life?

christianeamanpour

Introduction: The Podium Test and Why It Matters

Imagine a moment when a scientist stands before the world and says: “We found life beyond Earth.” This moment is what NASA calls the podium test. The point at which a scientist feels confident enough to share that claim with a global audience.

This is a big moment. For many scientists, the bar is very high. Strong evidence like fossils or technology would be undeniable. But most often, the first signs of life may be much subtler, hidden in chemicals, in the environment, or in patterns we have yet to fully understand.

This article explores how we search for life, what counts as good evidence, and how the world might one day pass that podium test. We’ll look at what’s happening on Mars today, gaze at distant exoplanets, and think about ocean worlds and the search for intelligent life. Along the way, we’ll ask and answer big questions that people keep asking.

What Counts as Evidence of Life?

Scientists use careful steps to decide if something truly points to life. Here is a clear, easy-to-follow list called the Confidence of Life Detection Scale (also known as the Ladder of Life Detection):

  • Detect a possible signal of life.
  • Rule out contamination by Earth life.
  • Make sure life could live there.
  • Rule out non-living explanations.
  • Find more signals that support the idea.
  • Rule out other hypotheses.
  • Get independent confirmation.

As Carl Sagan wisely said, “Life is the hypothesis of last resort.” Scientists work hard to make sure nothing else could explain what they see.

Mars: What We’re Learning from the Red Planet

Kevin Gill
Photo by Kevin Gill CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Mars has been a key place to look for past life.

In March 2025, NASA’s Curiosity rover found the longest organic molecules ever seen on Mars: decane, undecane, and dodecane, an carbon chains up to 12 atoms long in a 3.7-billion-year-old mudstone called Cumberland. These molecules may come from fatty acids, chemicals common in living cells. On Earth, fatty acids are often made by life, though chemistry can make them too. Still, this discovery raises hope that signs of life can survive for billions of years on Mars.

Separately, Curiosity has found carbonates minerals like siderite in rock layers at Gale Crater. This supports the idea that early Mars had a carbon cycle and a thicker atmosphere, meaning liquid water might have existed in the past. Water plus organics makes the planet more likely once to have supported life.

More recently, in September 2025, the Perseverance rover made a thrilling find. From rock in Jezero Crater called the Sapphire Canyon sample, scientists detected minerals like vivianite and greigite. On Earth, these often form when microbes interact with mud. The rocks also show leopard spots patterning and organic carbon signs that could come from ancient microbes. But scientists are cautious. These findings are potential biosignatures, and could still come from non-living chemistry.

These Mars findings are exciting. They fill many steps on the life detection ladder: signals exist, life may be possible, and abiotic explanations are being ruled out. But the final step in getting us to the podium needs the sample return and deeper lab tests. A recent article on What If 3I-ATLAS Hit Mars? makes us think more on life beyond our solar system.

Ocean Worlds: Exploring Europa and Enceladus

NASA / Jet Propulsion Lab-Caltech / SETI Institute
Photo by NASA / Jet Propulsion Lab-Caltech / SETI Institute Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Far beyond Mars, some moons in our solar system may still host life today.

Jupiter’s moon Europa and Saturn’s Enceladus have icy shells over oceans of salty water. Older designs suggest they might hide living organisms beneath the ice. But these samples are tiny. They need to be collected by fast spacecraft with limited instruments and they must be kept free from Earth contamination.

Still, the possibility that life might be extant, living now makes these worlds especially interesting. Subtle chemical clues, tiny organisms, or unexpected energy sources might show signs of life. But again, the podium test requires resisting false positives and contamination.

Exoplanets: Searching from Light-Years Away

For planets around other stars, we rely on telescopes and light.

The James Webb Space Telescope observed an exoplanet named K2-18 b in April 2025. It sits in its star’s "habitable zone" and might be a so-called "hycean world", an ocean-covered planet with a hydrogen-rich atmosphere. Webb detected gases like dimethyl sulfide (DMS) and dimethyl disulfide (DMDS), which on Earth are made by living microbes. This may be the strongest hint yet of life beyond our solar system but scientists are careful. Geological or chemical processes might still explain the gases.

Illustration: NASA
Photo by Illustration: NASA ESA, CSA, Ralf Crawford (STScI), Joseph Olmsted (STScI) Science: Nikku Madhusudhan (IoA), Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Some worry DMS isn't a reliable biosignature. There are models where UV light, methane, and hydrogen sulfide could create DMS without life. We must confirm with multiple observations before getting too excited.

Finding life at this distance means spotting really big signs, like changes in a planet’s atmosphere or surface color visible from far away.

Technosignatures: Signs of Intelligent Life

What if advanced life exists and can we detect it?

Technosignatures are signs of technology like radio signals, laser flashes, or artificial chemicals. NASA studies them carefully, in hopes of seeing signs of intelligent life.

These are big clues if we found one, it would pass the podium test immediately. But detecting them is very rare, and we have to rule out Earth-based interference or wrong signals.

Confirmation, Contamination, and Community Scrutiny

A claim of life must stand up to rigorous testing and global scientific review. Contamination is a real concern. Spacecraft can carry Earth microbes to other planets, making it hard to be sure life found is truly alien. This is why cleanliness, careful planning, and independent examination matter.

Scientific results must be replicable. Peer review, independent observations, and cross-checks help ensure false alarms are caught. Only with wide consensus can the community and humanity feel ready to stand behind the podium claim.

Where We’re Headed

NASA's Scientific Visualization Studio - KBR Wyle Services
Photo by NASA's Scientific Visualization Studio - KBR Wyle Services LLC/Jonathan North, KBR Wyle Services, LLC/Walt Feimer, NASA/GSFC/Claire Andreoli, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Scientists are already building the tools we need next.

NASA’s Habitable Worlds Observatory is a future telescope planned to launch around the 2040s. It will directly image exoplanets and search for signs of life in their atmospheres and surfaces. Other missions aim to explore Europa and Enceladus, even if first steps are small.

Each new mission, technique, or result takes us closer to that moment. Searching matters. It answers one of the deepest questions: Are we alone? And every step we take, subtle or bold, brings us closer to that answer.

Conclusion: The Podium Belongs to “We”

Finding life beyond Earth isn't a moment for one person. It’s for all humanity. From Mars to icy moons to planets around other stars where each world offers unique clues. Scientists use careful tests, multiple hypotheses, and global peer review. We guard against contamination and false alarms. Step by step, we climb the ladder of life detection.

And one day, the scientific community may gather, the evidence will be strong, and we will quietly, confidently say: “We found life.”

1 days ago
article writes info

Recommended Posts

Table of Contents

  • Introduction: The Podium Test and Why It Matters
  • What Counts as Evidence of Life?
  • Mars: What We’re Learning from the Red Planet
  • Ocean Worlds: Exploring Europa and Enceladus
  • Exoplanets: Searching from Light-Years Away
  • Technosignatures: Signs of Intelligent Life
  • Confirmation, Contamination, and Community Scrutiny
  • Where We’re Headed
  • Conclusion: The Podium Belongs to “We”